Tuesday 27 January 2009

Comparing MBSA, MU, WSUS, Essentials 2007 and SMS 2003

Supported Software and Content
Product:MBSAMicrosoft UpdateWindows Server Update ServicesEssentials 2007SMS 2003
Supported Software and ContentSame as MU for security update detection. Windows, IE, Exchange and SQL config checksWindows 2000+, Exchange 2000+, SQL Server 2000+, Office XP+ with expanding supportSame as MUSame as WSUS 3.0 + third-party and custom updatesSame as WSUS + NT 4.0 & Win98* + can update any other Windows based software
Content Types SupportedService Packs and Security UpdatesAll software updates, driver updates, service packs (SPs), and feature packs (FPs)Same as MU with only critical driver updatesAll updates, SPs & FPs, + third-party and custom updates & .MSI & .EXE based app installsAll updates, SPs, & FPs + supports update & app installs for any Windows based software
Security Update Management Capabilities
ProductMBSAMicrosoft UpdateWindows Server Update ServicesEssentials 2007SMS 2003
Supported Software and ContentSimpleNoSimpleIntermediateAdvanced
Network Bandwidth OptimizationNoYesYesYesYes
Update Distribution ControlNoNoSimpleAdvancedAdvanced
Update Installation & Scheduling FlexibilityNoManual & end user controlledSimpleAdvancedAdvanced
Update Installation Status ReportingSimpleInstall errors reported to user. Lists missing updates for accessing computerSimpleAdvancedAdvanced
Deployment PlanningNoNoSimpleIntermediateAdvanced
Inventory ManagementNoNoNoIntermediateAdvanced
Compliance CheckingYesNoNo – status reporting onlyInformal compliance status and reportingAdvanced

No comments:

Post a Comment